They should change it IMO

View:
Threaded
Linear
Threaded
#1
Cael
0
Frags
+
–

The fact that the first to make grand finals has 2 days off should be enough of a reward for the team or maybe like 1 ban prio but 2days off and 2 bans adv kinda much ngl

#2
jixk
1
Frags
+
–

1st ban 1st pick and one extra map pick so 1st seed basically decides the order of the maps being played should be enough since that team generally has a good map pool

#3
CaxTonYT
0
Frags
+
–

There's like a 20% chance vit wins this.

#4
JoepBakhuizen
-1
Frags
+
–

Yet the 2 map ban still hasn't mattered in most finals. So its a bit iffy

#5
Cael
0
Frags
+
–

I mean if u shoot a gun blinfolded and hit the target, that doesn't mean it's as easy to do as if u weren't blindfolded.
Like it makes it hellllla in favor to the first team, not only u get to basically choose the maps u also have 2 days to practice these maps so that u start off the series strong, which can put u in a mental adv aswell. Champs are only once a year but if we had a bigger sample size im sure it would show itself more clearly. The teams that won like that so far were beating the odds

#6
Zelestia
0
Frags
+
–

They are in the upper for a reason. And haven't lost a match in playoffs.

#8
Cael
0
Frags
+
–

Yeah cool but u only had to play 2 games to play for this adv u win 2 maps barely and u get to suddenly be thanos of the tournament it should be enough to get prio on pick and u have 2 days off while the other team is also playing more so showing more strats + playing back to back the most important games of the tourney which is taxing physically and mentally. That should be enough of an adv.

The upper finalists basically get to be the lobby admin i think that's too much.

#18
lang_
0
Frags
+
–

it is huge

#7
Graviest
0
Frags
+
–

I mean the way double elimination works in val, it kinda makes sense to give Loud these advantages. every team is allowed to lose a game and regroup but if Loud lose tomorrow that's just it. there's no bracket resets like in some other double elim formats. winning that upper final game should give you these advantages to make up for that

#9
Cael
0
Frags
+
–

Huh? but there is no bracket reset u just play 1 more game that's already the adv of upper by itself that u have a life line. Then u alr have the adv of being safely in the final having days off to prac or cool off whatever while the other team is playing back to back the most important games for them showing hella strats at that.

They should get to have 1st pick on both map and ban and thats's it. It makes the whole thing less competetive in itself for no reason. In other games u rarely get that much adv in the biggest tournament of the year.

Normally everyone agrees that not having to go to the lower bracket is an adv in itself.

"If loud lose tommorow" what are we talking about here? yeah what about if ANY OTHER TEAM lose today yesterday tommorow lol that's the same shit u either lose and are out or u win. u only benefit from the double elim at the beggining of the tournament

#13
Graviest
0
Frags
+
–

i don't think you get it
"if ANY OTHER TEAM lose today yesterday tommorow lol that's the same shit u either lose and are out or u win" except Vitality was allowed to lose to Loud and still recover. Loud will not have the same grace if they lose tomorrow. there would be almost no point in trying in the upper finals if all they got was a first ban (some teams even prefer other team to ban first in case of having similar map pools) it's almost like they're being rewarded for getting here without losing a match

#16
Graviest
0
Frags
+
–

and about the lower team having to play back to back games, some teams can even benefit from having momentum while the upper team can show up in any form. just from going back to last few winners:
Lev-won from lowers
NS-flawless run from uppers
NRG-flawless run from uppers
PRX-flawless run from uppers
T1-won from lowers
it really isn't that big of a deal. this format is fine. Vitality should've just won that upper game if it mattered that much

#17
Cael
0
Frags
+
–

Lmao, i dont think u get it. Loud was allowed to lose to vitality too. Vitality wont have the same grace tommorow just like loud.
U act like 2 days off, not playing back to back and first ban and first map pick(u get to have comfort) is not enough of a reward if u are supposedly the better team lol.

U are also forgetting that going to the lowers is NOT a reward its a punishment so one team is getting big rewards while the other is getting a punishment it tips the scale hard in favor of one team and im not talking abt loud but any team in that position, it kinda defeats the purpose of competetive play.

Especially since 1 is a bo3 and the other is a bo5 u get rewarded for being the better bo3 team and if by chance u are the worse bo5 team (should matter the most) worry not we got u covered in the final, u get to pick and choose all ur opponent maps while also getting time to prac them some more yaaay!

#19
Graviest
0
Frags
+
–

bro i genuinely do not understand where the disconnect is happening. Every team has 2 lives except the one team who wins the upper final. and yes it is a punishment for losing that game, the punishment is that you will have to play with no bans. while I can agree that maybe upper final should be a bo5, that would just make the first day of finals just drag on much longer. this format is just fine, if it were as much of an advantage as you keep putting it, the winner of every event we've ever had would've come from uppers, and that is just not the case

#10
Anguibok
0
Frags
+
–

We should have a final 4 in semifinal instead of having a team that will play twice the same team in a raw.

Double or even triple lower bracket is perfect until we arrive in the final 4

#11
Cael
0
Frags
+
–

true it should, could be like a typical tie breakers last matches are basically 2 teams go thru from lowers and land on the side of bracket to prevent playing twice but if u can't do that then at least prevent regionals and if u cant do that too then well nothing u can do but still better format propably than having to play back to back finals and giving an insane adv to the other team in a competetive S+ tier tournament

#12
Anguibok
0
Frags
+
–

Winner of winner bracket would be allowed to pick their opponent so we are sure the top 2 team meet in final if the best team isnt délulu

#14
Cael
0
Frags
+
–

i meant more like 2 or 4 teams get to go thru "double elim" and its over for that bracket and u start the playoffs clean from there where its single elim and u avoid rematches and regionals as much as possible, like ofc what im saying is not polished its just an idea but i think giving the benefit of the doubt at the beggining to the teams to then cut it and make it no more mistakes single elim, that would delete the adv for upper bracket finalists and u would just have 2 teams no strings attached

#15
Anguibok
0
Frags
+
–

BO5 single elim only for the top 4 allow mistakes, I think thats the good balance. Single elim is bad for 8 teams but good for 4 if we have a system that prevent the 2 best team to play each other

  • Preview
  • Edit
› check that that your post follows the forum rules and guidelines or get formatting help
Sign up or log in to post a comment