I wouldn't call NaVi tier 2. They were constantly facing best of EMEA in VCT and especially Cloud was doing really well. He changed roles because he is flexible and NaVi doesn't have good Raze player. Guy made his name as Sova, but can play KayO, Raze, Skye etc. And likely on Giants he is going back to main initiator role.
Giants has a lot of potential with some really good players. Rhyme is the biggest questionmark tho because his ability to lead and possibly move to controller role is bit unknown at the moment. And will remain to be seen how Fit1nho performs against tier 1 competition nowadays. But overall the firepower and experience of Nukkye, Hoody and Cloud is already really high. Nukkye has been superstar in the past and arguably even rn and Cloud has potential to be one after his team starts doing better.
Apparently Rhyme was already IGL in GenG, team didn't do too well so we'll have to see about his IGLing skills, maybe on a controller role it's easier and he is a really really flexible player so it should be fine with the role change. His numbers shouldn't be too bas as IGL we'll see how he does, if they chose him I wanna think is for a reason.
About Fitinho I have high hopes on him but trying to be as objetive as possibly he is gonna be an average duelist on the league, not the worst, not the best, hopefully he brings impact tho cause numbers and firepower is definitely not what this roster needs
Discord