APAC COME

View:
Threaded
Linear
Threaded
#1
lez
4
Frags
+
–

I have a genuine question. Jake Sin's explaination for the subregion split in Pacific is that teams were already forming national rosters rather than a mix for SEA talent to form a superteam, and that it guarantees each subregion representation in the Cups.

So my question is, would you have rather SEA be combined into one subregion and lose out on representation (ie. 3 IND/3 THAI qual and no Viet or PH teams) or the current split where you have a home team that is guaranteed into Cups and can root for?

#2
mulyondoindon
3
Frags
+
–

just don't split SEA

#3
merciless-pity8989-89
0
Frags
+
–

why shouldn’t they?

#4
mulyondoindon
2
Frags
+
–

cause we already know what happens.
They already kill T2 at SEA, so the split only hurt the player pools even more

#8
lez
0
Frags
+
–

I'd argue this split helps the T2 players more than hurts them. With this change, they only need to beat 1 partnered team to make it into Cups and can earn money just from reaching the Cups.

If you combine SEA, they would have to beat PRX/FS/RRQ/GAM, who have all the money to attract talent and you'll have no hope of making it.

#9
mulyondoindon
0
Frags
+
–

it is a good split IF they didn't do that soop partnership in the past.

They hurt the viewer base and many teams dip out from the T2 scenes.

On a perfect scenario, this split could actually make APAC stronger

#10
lez
0
Frags
+
–

Yeah but that perfect scenario doesn't exist and the SOOP partnership has already happened. The past can't be changed and shouldn't be a point in this argument.

#11
NongshimBeliever
1
Frags
+
–

It helps the bad T2 players not the good ones, stronger t2 teams in Korea fight for a singular spot while being vastly better than the other regions

#15
lez
0
Frags
+
–

I agree with that and I also think Korea got snubbed. But my question is more directed towards SEA as I'm curious about their thoughts, since most have been wanting to combine the subregions

#5
potofgold
0
Frags
+
–

americas have 4 subregions we have 7, seems about right

#6
PP12123213123
0
Frags
+
–

SEA doesn't have many orgs in the first place, and it's similar to EU where cross-country SEA rosters are a normal thing. That's not just the case in Valorant either, but across many other esports games as well

#12
thatpower
0
Frags
+
–

SEA teams besides prx don't mix nationalities as much as EMEA. They usually maintain around three players of the same nationality or more

#13
lez
1
Frags
+
–

Thats not true though. If you look at the history of SEA orgs in Pacific, most of them always had 3/5 from their home region. GE and PRX are the exceptions. Even for PRX, their roster this year and when they won Toronto had 3/5 from RoSEA.

#14
PP12123213123
0
Frags
+
–

ROSEA is not a real thing. It's just the region that Riot created to seperate indo thai vn to boost viewership

#16
lez
0
Frags
+
–

Yes, but thats how Riot has divided the region. I'm more looking for which side do the SEA fans prefer since most are complaning about the split

#24
noronoro
0
Frags
+
–

SEA doesnt have much talents anyway, looks RRQ, there is no news or anything, because there is nit enough good player that can compete at t1 level

#7
EspoirCity
0
Frags
+
–

they should merge japan qualifier slot with SEA just like challenger (without korea ofc)
3 slot for japan is crazy

#30
r1uk3nd0
0
Frags
+
–

Exactly

#17
jixk
0
Frags
+
–

Jake Sin's explaination for the subregion split in Pacific is that teams were already forming national rosters rather than a mix for SEA talent to form a superteam, and that it guarantees each subregion representation in the Cups.

that would be great if they did it for any other region but they didnt so it just looks even more stupid let SEA import into SEA and or undice them if you cant

you dont lose any representation orgs will still form a team with 5 players from there country/region splitting up SEA only affects team who want to run mixed rosters

#19
lez
0
Frags
+
–

SEA be combined into one subregion and lose out on representation (ie. 3 IND/3 THAI qual and no Viet or PH teams)

Losing represention doesn't refer to the team formations but more of representation in Cups.

#20
jixk
0
Frags
+
–

teams will build fully national or mixed rosters regardless of what riot doesnt or does and with OQ there always be a repping team it only affects T1 teams/orgs not having the option to run mixed rosters at all in SEA and no other sub-region has this issue

it is unfair to SEA teams especially for a non-issue like rep with OQ and emea has 3 french teams with zero french players

#21
lez
0
Frags
+
–

I don't understand the EMEA arguement. The region splits have been consistent since the beginning to VCT. Pre-partnership EMEA was also split into EU, MENA, Turkey, CIS (CIS doesn't exist anymore for reasons) but nobody complained about it back in 2021, why complain now?

#23
jixk
0
Frags
+
–

SEA wasn't split into indo,viet,thai and roSEA and didn't add import restrictions to T1 teams making it impossible to run mixed roster unlike EU it is unfair

and pre partnership it was SEA btw

#28
lez
0
Frags
+
–

That is completely false. Pre-partnership SEA qualified to internationals through Asia-Pacific Challengers but to get into APAC Challengers teams qualfied through their own subregion challengers. It was even more split back then as PH & MYSG had their own subregion rather than the current RoSEA. Thats why PRX had 3/5 MYSG players back then (Benkai/Shiba/Davai -> Benkai/Jing/Davai)

https://www.vlr.gg/event/1063/champions-tour-asia-pacific-stage-2-challengers-playoffs/playoffs

#29
jixk
0
Frags
+
–

SEA wasn't split into indo,viet,thai and roSEA and didn't add import restrictions to T1 teams making it impossible to run mixed

this is talking about partnership/T2 which is the relevant talent pool not whatever was going on in 2021 which is irrelevant i was incorrect that it was sea pre partner ship

regardless having no option to run a mixed roster when every other region can or didn't have there talent pool diced 4 into post partnership is unfair either make the french teams run 3 french players or let SEA have a option to run mixed rosters and not be split into 6+ sub regions

#18
spunkspray
0
Frags
+
–

think about it. Four years SEA bros has constantly cringed that about kicking korean players on their teams. Segregating by nationality makes perfect sense in a region like Asia, where everyone is an ultranationalist. deep down, they’d probably agree with that.
But of course, different rules should apply to a "our" superteam PRX.

#22
Anguibok
0
Frags
+
–

You raised here the most important debate in APAC val. And we saw that SEA guys did complain both when merge and split.

To me it was good to split because everyone will feel represented in cups and thats what we want, if you dont do that you can create a snowball effect where a decent region like Indo dont manage to qual and the region start to loose slowly interest of the game making the reagion weaker.

I understand the complain of "But we cant have a team with a mix of SEA anymore", and I think we could have the best of both world :

  • National tournament with 4 to 8 teams where top 1 is qualified to cup
  • LCQ swiss with 16 teams, with an open qual where any team with a mixed roster can participate. with at leas 2 spots

That way if a team really really want to have a mixed roster they are allowed to, and they can qual.

But we also need to go to 16 team in cups cause 12 team format is shit and 16 is perfect :

  • 1 TH
  • 1 ID
  • 1 VN
  • 2 RoSEA (Either that, or 1PH and 1RoSEA)
  • 2 LCQ-SEA
  • 2 KR
  • 2 JP
  • 1 RoEA (MN, TW, East-RU, Micronesia)
  • 2 LCQ-EA (Wish mean it's almost 4 slot for KR guarantee, so dont get fool by only 2 slot for KR)
  • 1 SA
  • 1 OCE

(SA and OCE doenst participate to an LCQ)

I also think a similar system should be created in Europe

#25
jixk
0
Frags
+
–

since no other region was split up like this except SEA teams we have 3 french orgs with zero french players while SEA gets split up and doesnt have the option at all to run mixed rosters it feels kind of unfair especially since mixed rosters are are the main reason SEA is competitive in the first place if there was a canada team they would be able to run US players with no issues etc

also with the qualification spots split you still have a issue of representation if 2 good teams play in the same sub-region one of them will always get snubbed and that also leads to losing interest not to mention if that other roster couldn't compare to cup level teams cause they cant run the best possible roster

also if SEA T1 teams can't run the best possible roster(mixed) and every other sub-region in every other region has the ability to run mixed(or the same talent pool they have always had) roster and beat the team without the option to run a mixed roster that will also lead to lost interest

i think a decent solution is giving SEA teams a import exemption on a SEA player so 2 import slots 1 SEA exemption and 2 subregion players i feel like that is mixed enough if it isnt make it 2 import 2 SEA exemption 1 subregion player so at worst 1 player is repping while the org isn't at a inherent disadvantage against international competition + there will always be a org/roster with 5 players repping the region

SEA guys did complain both when merge and split.

i think this time its mainly about how the T1 team dont have a option to run mixed roster at all compared to international competition(or smaller talent pool in comparison) not the sub-region themselves i think there fine but if there was a little flexiblity with SEA exemptions to make the smaller talent pool hurt less especially when SEA already had talent pool issues compared to korea

#26
Anguibok
0
Frags
+
–

since no other region was split up like this except SEA

They are no reason to split any other region, every region in the world is monolungual, SEA and EU are the 2 sole exception (With maybe MENA if you count Iran and maybe Pak, but thats exceptons), NA, LAS, LAN, BR, CN, JP, KR, TR all of this is 1 unique region, anywhere in the world it's "1 region, 1 language, 1 scrimpool". The only place where we can ask ourself "should we split" is indeed SEA and EU

we have 3 french orgs with zero french players while SEA gets split up and doesnt have the option at all to run mixed rosters it feels kind of unfair especially

Import destroyed french talents. Our young talent couldn't have the opportunity to shine, because half or opportunity where for already good player that where import. Did M8 needed an import to qualify ? No. Look at EU and LNA qualifier, team with a 3-french core did insanely well, we had like 20% of team with a French core roster in the top 64 in EU, and we took 25% of places (La Masia and F9). Same for Russian. Same with french core in LNA qualifier, OQ 1 final was literrally Belgium core vs French core. And lets admit for a second we are too weak to have a roster with 3 french, okay, What about that change of rule (That remind me the one your proposed later): In SEA and EU, team are allowed to have 2 import from anywhere + 1 import from EU/SEA. You wont convince me its impossible to make a good team with 2 french player + 3 imports.

since mixed rosters are are the main reason SEA is competitive in the first place if there was a canada team they would be able to run US players with no issues etc

This isnt true RRQ did well with 3 Indo, TS had a core with 3 PH player for most of their time (And didnt went better when they stop having 3 PH player, and technically TS would have 3 player from RoSEA), and PRX is a team that blossomed during split region ERA, and Thai team almost always have 5 thai player. Maybe the mistake was to put MYSG with PH instead of Indo, since MY and ID speak the same language with a different standard. During half of their history PRX did have like either 3 Indo or 3 MYSG, and ALWAYS had 3 ID-MYSG player. Just make an ID-MYSG region, and everything is fine (PH can even enjoy having their region back lul). This is not true to say that making region in SEA will make team weaker, when all of them always have 3 player from the same subregion.

also with the qualification spots split you still have a issue of representation if 2 good teams play in the same sub-region one of them will always get snubbed

Just make an LCQ ! We could totally imagine a system with 16 team qualified in cups (Wish would solve the bad format we have with 12 teams), where half of themcoming from national league, and half come from EU LCQ (We could even let mixed team participate in LCQ, this is open to debate)

#27
Shadow_Monarch
0
Frags
+
–

At least 5 solid good SuperTeams in APAC. The rest of the teams will all be shit anyways.

  • Preview
  • Edit
› check that that your post follows the forum rules and guidelines or get formatting help
Sign up or log in to post a comment