game changers

View:
Threaded
Linear
Threaded
#1
wintery
0
Frags
+
–

theres lots of commotion about gc and the trans community in the vlr posts atm so as a chud dumbass i decided to voice my opinions

trans people are real people with feelings, so any debates about gc shouldnt allow for transphobia

but also i think gc as a concept isnt serving its purpose of providing a safe space for marginalised genders to compete in valorant, and it also means that top gc players arent really trying their luck in t1/t2 teams because gc is safer and pays well, even though they have the potential to do well (we saw how mimi and noia worked with tier 2 players on the danish team) which means that the growth and talent pool of marginalised genders will just never grow and that would be a shame

#2
termtermtermterm
2
Frags
+
–

personally I dont think GC's purpose was to grant a safe space but rather a pathway into valo esports economically for marginalized genders

#4
wintery
0
Frags
+
–

yeah but has that rlly worked

#5
termtermtermterm
0
Frags
+
–

considering the success of SRG, G2.G, TLV, and others, yes I would say it has worked

#6
wintery
0
Frags
+
–

what success have they had
arent they all mid in their t2 region

#7
Vyse-Fan_In-more-than-one
0
Frags
+
–

Getting them into the sport: Yes
Getting them farther than the tier 2.5 Game changers is: No

#9
wintery
0
Frags
+
–

fair enough

#3
peetherium
0
Frags
+
–

The GC argument is weird because the whole point of GC is to foster community in gender demographics that are already under represented across the board. That's literally the whole point. Trying to argue against it in favor of "competitive integrity" is a losing battle from the start because that point inherently misunderstands the main reason for why it exists in the first place

#13
wintery
0
Frags
+
–

idk i js want my gc goats in a tier 2 team 😔😔😔

#14
peetherium
0
Frags
+
–

Bob and Flor both proved that GC talent can exist in tier 2 systems independently from their GC teams. It's only a matter of time before talent in Game Changers consolidates and develops to a point of whole teams competing decently well in tier 2. It's a guarantee given enough time.

#17
verybluepond
1
Frags
+
–

bob is not exactly GC talent considering she played for soniqs pre-c9w. I think faster partial parity at least at t2 could be achieved if it was easier to integrate .01% gc talent into t2 teams, but that's wishing for an ideal environment. The entire state of things is just eh, and there's definitely a few better timelines where we had proper gc results pre-franchising, but whatever

#20
peetherium
1
Frags
+
–

Yeah her development was way more streamlined and separated from everyone else in the circuit but it is a good framework of what we can possibly expect later on. Might be too optimistic about the future conditions GC players will face while they try developing in proper co-ed environments (I am ngl) but it's not a stretch to say that in proper conditions the prospective talents a few years down the line will be cool to see

#8
Galactc
1
Frags
+
–

Takes aside the number of people who don't know that gc is for marginalised genders is wild reading comprehension is at an all time low or something

#10
wintery
1
Frags
+
–

the transphobes js dont care about gc but are transphobic so spew bullshit without researching

#12
Livvie
4
Frags
+
–

transphobes dont care about women either

#11
Castawaytwizz
0
Frags
+
–

ngl I don't even agree with them but it might just be you having a weak theory of mind of the people you oppose, everybody knows they're allowed to compete their argument is they believe the rules should change

#15
verybluepond
0
Frags
+
–

I don't really get the point though. Any female competitor wishing for a "safer place to compete" away from trans people is not going to get very far anyway. Why is everybody suddenly pro "womens-only" competitive spaces? there's no way any actual competitor wants that

#16
Castawaytwizz
0
Frags
+
–

i mean people have always supported those things in traditional sports, its just people carrying the same beliefs over to esports. its just the belief that "people born male/underwent male puberty have an inherent advantage so must be separated from those born female when competing" but idk if that really holds up in esports tbh

from what i can see the research is inconclusive and there hasnt really been a clear cut advantage found

#18
verybluepond
0
Frags
+
–

the only decent paper I've read on it uses n=4 women as sample size, and none of these people are professional esports players. The difference is also like ~20ms, so there's a good argument for that being inconsequential. I do not think Mel or noia is slower than the average t1 player with regards to choice RT. I also think everyone the whole of idea of splitting the inclusivity program further just sounds stupid

here u go for ref: https://doi.org/10.4103/2229-516x.157168

#21
Castawaytwizz
0
Frags
+
–

yeah i mean im not saying i agree with those people i just dont think it helps anybody to pretend their argument is something its not

#19
fawning
1
Frags
+
–

idk my problem with gc that there's multiple failed t3 "pros" or rank ladder players that suddenly are nobinary or anything else to play in GC

  • Preview
  • Edit
› check that that your post follows the forum rules and guidelines or get formatting help
Sign up or log in to post a comment