The eye test is good and all but it's very subjective, I literally instantly thought Mada was always taking 1st engagements I didn't even know it THIS much since till I saw the stats. The thing about s0m and Ethn not hesistating to take aim duels is something I disagree on not that it's bad but they don't try to as much they could be.
I don't think 100% of his inconsistency is due to the amount of first engagements but I think it's definitely a big part of it. It's definitely not enough to say it's the duelist job to take first engagements when NRG are such a big outlier in this compared to every other team.THIS IS NOT NORML.
Like think about it from mada's prespective for a second, either he dies first in which case he doesn't get to play out the round when everyone is low on health and util or if he wins his aim duel he's more than likely not low on health and util. In the sceanarios he's put in he'll rarely have the chance to get some of the easier kills brawk does. Don't underestimate the luxury Brawk has in clutches e.g knowing everybody's position, having to deal with less util and being against low hp enemies. Mada rarely ever has this luxury.