You're simply ignoring the argument. You cannot make a conclusion when there is not enough evidence. Eggsterr consistently performed in VCL because he was comfortable with his team and his agent. Rankers did not play the meta, and yet they managed to win almost all of their games. Although T2 and T1 are clearly not the same, today's game against MIBR indicates that perhaps meta picks are overrated. Your argument that a 1-trick is terrible because of meta shifts is simply hard to support, and your claim that Eggsterr is terrible because of his poor performance in a new environment is naive. Eggsterr has shown that he has plenty of talent before, and you simply cannot say that he is terrible when he is playing in a environment that is not conducive to his success. ENVY's current roster lacks chemistry; Eggsterr and Poppin alluded to it in their post-match interview and their live comms support the idea. Ultimately, Eggsterr likely would've been able to perform quite well with the original Ranker's core in VCT, but we can never know for certain.