Yes, she exceeds by being a great squad manager and potentializing every player individually through the collective. But that is always limited by the squad she chooses to play. Sometimes the ceilling isn't too high and we got just competent enough players.
2023 EG was a squad with good players that became great with her + the addition of a generational talent like Demon1 that truly changed the mindset of the team. 2024 lacked the individual greatness of the team, was a more budgeted version that always got limited by having less talented players (and Jawgemo alone can't carry a team)
My point is: i think shes overtated because sometimes people treat her like she's the main cause for EG success, but she's only one factor. That 2023 run was insane for a number of equally important reasons. But she's still great and will win another major trophy as soon as she has a better squad (if she even wants one)