chichoo was not the best senti - meteor was. chichoo was probably second. smoggy was the best fragging smokes, but it's not like there are many smokes players that focus on fragging (util hungry). nobody wasn't the best igl, i think mako and boo had better ideas throughout the tournament. kk was probably the best duelist, but it's a lot easier to be the "best duelist" if you have a util demon behind you.
again, these players are all still around. nothings changed, apart from s1mon leaving. they went from champs, 3rd to failing to qualify from the weakest region. fnc replaced leo with hiro and still did well, edg went from top 3 in the world to looking completely lost.
kk is an extremely selfish duelist. there's nothing wrong with it, it's a fine playstyle, creates space for your team yada yada. it works and it's really fun to watch. that said, he needs immense util cover from his supports for his style to work. aspas you can just plonk on jett and he'll find you entries even if his team is afk. kk relies on his supports far, far more than any other duelist player. again, nothing wrong with it - it's a really effective style if you assume you have the support behind you. that's a big if.
there's an intrinsic, fundamental tradeoff between how much you shoot and how much util you use. if you're shooting someone, it means you aren't piling util on them and letting your teammates shoot them. smoggy, chichoo, kk all love shooting people. they're good at it, it works. again, nothing wrong with it. they tailor their game plan and agents (clove, no senti comps) to revolve around them. nobody's util was also fine, he is a good pos4 player, but nothing specifically impressed me more than other top tier pos4 players. s1mon was a monstrous pos5, singlehandedly making up for the util deficiency that the other 3 shooters on his team inevitably creates.
like just look at fnc for instance. kaajak is a pretty selfish duelist, but not as much as kk i'd say. alfa is around the same as chichoo in terms of util demand. boaster provides waaaaaaay more util than smoggy, and chronicle provides a bit more util than nobody. that makes crashies's life a hell of a lot easier than s1mon's.
i also think people overstate him being "emotional" or whatnot. like, the lotus 1v2 clutch was the most ice-cold, perfect decisionmaking + positioning, optimal play in what was probably the most impactful round of the series (maybe minus the guardian 4k abyss). idk what comms videos you're watching but he's vocal with his flashes and play coordination.
he's a rookie, and it was his first ever international tournament, and he gets insane hate for having bad-looking stats, and consequently gets scapegoated everytime edg loses, despite him probably being the best player on the team. i ain't gonna claim i empathise with the guy, cause i have no clue what competing on a world stage would feel like, but i can say for sure that being in a spot like that ain't easy. i think he let the hate get to him, which is such a shame.
everyone whiffs on fully-flashed people from time to time. s1mon can shoot really well, his clutch rate was among the highest in the tournament. he just doesn't get a chance to take the good fights, you can't kill people while piling your util on them. unironically, i think he knew he was getting benched in that last game vs nova, and just said fuck it i'm playing for myself this game and ended up top fragging.