geng made 5/6 finals in 2024 and looked dominant in toronto with 2 new players. they beat both finalists at the tourney. from a macro standpoint i don't think they regressed one bit. they also came 3rd in kickoff going map 5 vs t1 and placed 2nd in stage 1.
a similar case can be argued for sen tbh, losing tenz and sacy and sen still qualified to all 3 events and made a decent placement (5th 6th) at toronto with 2 new players. they also performed well regionally.
termi has proved his consistency, same with mini
mini has proven it with FNATIC to the point where he can easily be a GM for a team
(btw, being a good coach does not automatically make you a gm. it's not a promotion. one is a position in an org, the other is a position in a team. they are 2 different things)
alecks always had the same 4 players on his team since 2022 until early 2025, which probably helps ngl. but i agree he is top 5.
after is an interesting shout but considering the circumstances around china as a region at the time alongside the fact edg didn't have any noticeably high placements i don't think he makes the cut. geng, sen, drx, fnc, prx all have one podium finish to speak to the peaks of the team. maybe muggle is a better choice