Michael Phelps
Usain bolt
Aleksandr kremlin. My top 3.
Anyway for other check this post of mine.
except for a couple many of these have been better in their fields.
https://www.vlr.gg/580935/greatest-athletes-oat/#19
Tbh just don't compare sports and esports Athletes. Not comparable at all until esports can be as accessible and widespread as sports and if the esports scene for a particular game can last centuries long like sports.